[Kane, Pat] We don't look at this as a
character variant issue, but an IDN support issue. If it makes sense
to limit the number of code points available for a valid Korean
registration, then we will consider it. As a note, out of 900k plus
IDNs in the com/net testbed greater than one third contain Hangul
characters. Out of those registrations, only 9 combine code points out
of the character sets that you reference. Six are combined with
Katakana characters and three are combined with Hiragana characters.
It seems to me a lot of development and maintenance work go into this
solution for something that rarely occurs naturally.
[AyeShil Jeon]
The key to the problem is
input/display difficulties in the current computer
environment
based on KS X 1001:1998 (commonly
known as euc-kr, korean local charset)
with the boundary of
2,350
Hangeul syllables.
Unix/Linux support 2,350 Hangeul
syllables and 4,888 Hanja and most PDA or pocket PC
are in the same boat to prevent
exhausting of memory although Hangeul related
solutions
are gearing up being at the mercy of
supporting the 11,172 Hangeul syllables, as a
Unicode-based system in the near
future.
But the reality of today
to deploy IDN is different a little bit from
that.
> And would you describe your
position about below problem that
>might be happen in Hangeul
:
>Some visual
ambiguities such as some example between "ㄱㅏ"(U+3130
U+314F)
>"가"(U+AC00) which might
make Internet users confused and bring in dispute,
>if VGRS keeps permitting
those Hangeul Compatibility jamo.
>So there are only
Unicode Hangeul Syllables in the table KRNIC gets underway.
[Kane, Pat] Without a table
describing what is permitted within a Hangeul registration it is difficult
to have a position. When following the IDNA RFC's there is nothing to
restrict the use of those Unicode code points within IDN
registrations.
[AyeShil Jeon]
What brought VGRS here to adopt
TWNIC's table? Isn't it the registration policy to
consider
each countrie's language-specific
issue? If you don't have such a table describing what is
permitted
within a Hangeul registration,
I'm looking forward to seeing some positive sign of VGRS to adopt it when
KRNIC make it.
Thank you,
AyeShil.