[12.5] "IDN MUST NOT return illegal code points in responses, SHOULD
reject queries with illegal codepoints." (1 request to add; 1 request
to remove)
I didn't see this thread on the mailing list. I like the statement,
and I would hope to see it in any protocol, but I'm not sure it is a
*requirement* for IDN.
[13] One request to remove.
That was me. :-) So far, all the drafts except one are either
ACE-only or a combination of binary-and-ACE. The one exception has
barely been discussed in many months. Thus, I really think [13] must
fall out (and should have never been there in the first place). What
is the justification for this requirement? It sounds like a design
goal for one of the protocols.
--Paul Hoffman, Director
--Internet Mail Consortium