[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Fwd: beep in calsch-cap-13.txt





From: David Blacka <davidb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>


Ted,

I've done a very quick scan of the document and nothing jumped out at me as being obviously wrong. That is, it didn't look like BEEP was being used in some impossible way. I did have a few initial comments, however:

* use of the "locales" attribute in the BEEP greeting to set the CAP locale might not be the best thing. the "locales" attribute appears to be for localizing BEEP error messages, and so I am unsure how appropriate it would be to re-use it for the CAP protocol itself. I am mainly unsure if implementations typically export that information.

* the one BEEP example needs work. For instance, the BEEP frame isn't fully shown, and probably should be.

I can spend a little be more time looking to see if there is something else CAP needs to specify (like the message pattern). I think it probably does, but I expect 3080 has something specific to say about it.

--
David