[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

RE: Software for PKI




At 8:20 AM +0200 11/14/01, Ben Goldman wrote:
Hi Steve,

From my experience in the IETF, the main working group list is meant to
specifically address the rfc issues and to reach a consensus for the
proposed standards. Usually there is an additional, more general discussion
list, where people can freely discuss additional concepts or theories
regarding the marketing, implementation and/or "real life" experiences
involved with the proposed standards.

From my experience it would greatly help the working group, and reduce the
load in the main list, if we will have an additional list side by side with
the main list. I had checked this issue with our web administrators, and it
would be possible to host this list for the working group.

People can send a subscribe request to
ietf-pkix-general-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

To Subscribe: ietf-pkix-general-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In Body: subscribe your_email_address (In Body)

My 2 Cents.

Ben


Ben,


I'm not sure what examples from other WGs you have in mind.

I think the official PKIX WG list, it the right place to discuss experience with implementations, etc., since that sort of discussion is needed to evolve the standards and if it takes place off list, the reintroduction of the discussions into the WG may be harder.

You are right that discussions about marketing do not belong on this list.

By the way, is "security-wg.com" a Cisco site? I ask since I assume you are the same Ben Goldman who is the Cisco product marketing manager for security products.

Steve