RE: Media Security Requirements Draft: New Requirement

["Christer Holmberg (JO/LMF)" <christer.holmberg@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi, 

>>>draft-wing-rtpsec-keying-eval-02.txt was the basis for my
presentation 
>>>at the first RAI open area meeting a couple of years back, and the 
>>>basis for my presentation at the first RTPSEC BoF.
>> 
>>Ok. So, does that draft take the issues currently discussed into 
>>consideration?
> 
>No, we haven't revised that document since you brought up 
>these requirements.  But the requirements you have mentioned 
>break how SIP functions pre-200 (irrespective of SRTP).

I guess that could be discussed, but this is not the place.

The main point is that I am telling how many networks (again, it's not
IMS specific) work today. 

But, if we don't want to take that into consideration I would suggest
that we clearly state, in order to avoiding having similar discussions
in the future, that the mechanism we are working on may not be
applicable to networks where these kind of functions exist.

Regards,

Christer