Re: WG Last Call: draft-ietf-sasl-scram-02

[Simon Josefsson <simon@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Chris Newman <Chris.Newman@xxxxxxx> writes:

> Section 7:
>>     generic-message = attr-val *("," attr-val)
>>                       ;; Generic syntax of any server challenge
>>                       ;; or client response
>
> I observe that gs2-header does not conform to "generic-message" if it
> begins with "y" or "n".  This inconsistency could be resolved by
> removing "generic-message" from the document.

The "generic-message" rule is never mentioned elsewhere (noticed by
running Bill Fenner's ABNF parser), so I would also prefer to remove the
rule.

/Simon