Re: draft-ietf-usefor-usepro-02

[Frank Ellermann <nobody@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Charles Lindsey wrote:
 
> I don't think there is any reason to forbid "reimport to
> Usenet" as such (for example, it may come back into Usenet
> in a different group and with a different message-id).
.......................^^^

>> you -> A - B - C -> me
>>        |   |
>>        a   b
>>        |   |
>>        other

>> I never see some of your articles in group ABC.test
[...]
> you have not explained to me why it never got to server C

"a" exported ABC.test to B.other in the other net,  Then "b"
reimported B.other to B.local on server B.  C doesn't get the
article in ABC.test.  The "and" in your statement (see above)
is important.
  
What "b" could do is to create a new Message-ID, quite the
opposite of your idea to preserve Message-IDs in the body.

> Have you ever met a gateway admin who would admit that he
> "didn't know what he was doing" :-)

Not in the former German "gateways" and "gatebau" groups, all
GiGo users were legend, and dead gateway admins don't post :-)

                        Bye, Frank