[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: #1053 Relationship to RFC 2822 - suggestion



Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote:

>| Handling of non-conformant articles is outside the scope of
>| this specification; agents may choose to accept such
>| articles, reject such articles

So far it's fine...

>| or modify such articles.

...but that's one of the things I'd not say in a standard, even
if it's true.  Let's say "may" ... "accept such articles", not
more.  Obviously there's an implicit "maybe not" (= reject),
don't talk about it, and there's also a very hidden implicit
"how they accept it is their business" (= modify), but don't
say it, it's out of scope.

> Does this make sense?

Yes, I like it better than the old terse text, but please don't
mention "modify", that's the private horror show of those who
try to pull this stunt (e.g. mail2news gateways, news servers
fixing the magic SP, etc.)
                             Bye, Frank