Re: #1132: Allowing IP addresses as path-identiites - Poll result

[Harald Tveit Alvestrand <harald@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

--On fredag, september 16, 2005 08:19:25 +0200 Frank Ellermann 
<nobody@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

>  path-diag     = [ [FWS] "!POSTED" ]
>                  [ "!" /                 ; match => "!!"
>                    ( [FWS] "!"
>                      ( IPv4address       ; see [RFC 3986]
>                      / IPv6address       ; see [RFC 3986]
>                      / path-identity ) ".MISMATCH" ) ]
>
> If you prefer your "lazy IP-diagnostics" = Charles' .SEEN
> please replace the ".MISMATCH" by ( ".SEEN" / ".MISMATCH" )
> in this proposal.

You've removed "path-keyword" - so what you're proposing is different from 
what's specified in the current documents, not just a different syntax.

I'm hesitant to change what's in the documents, but I think there's still 
no implementation of these features, and getting the keywords into the 
diagnostics rather than treating them separately appeals to me.

                  Harald