Re: #1416

[Dan Schlitt <schlitt@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I also think that Russ has the stronger position.

/dan

-- 

Dan Schlitt
schlitt@xxxxxxxxxxxxx


On Thu, 7 Aug 2008, Forrest J. Cavalier III wrote:

>
> Charles Lindsey wrote:
> > Agreed. Clearly Russ's vote for IR is cancelled out by my vote for IC, so
> > it is the rest of the WG that gets to make the choice. But we need to get
> > that choice made so that we can move on.
> >
>
> I'm with Russ, if that matters to the chair.
>
> I have no idea why every vote counts equally here, for two reasons.
>
> 1. Russ has experience writing and maintaining news server software for a
> production environment.  I do too.  Others here do too.
>
> 2. Technical merit matters.  I agree completely with Russ's statements
> about how rapidly software will get changed in production.  There is
> lots of evidence for that in the last decade.  I believe that
> the choices in what you call "IR" are appropriate for that.
>