[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Announcement of an I-D
Chris Lilley wrote:
> MURATA Makoto wrote:
> > Q1. If you introduce a media type "image/svg", you can certainly introduce
> > SVG-specific fragment
> > identifiers.
> There are two issues here.
> Firstly, since it is defining a media type, it needs to define what the
> fragment identifier syntax is. We use XPointer, but in this release
> restict it to pointing to IDs. This is because we want a spec that is
> fully implemented very rapidly.
> Later versions will probably remove this restriction, once XLink and
> XPointer are more established.
16.2.2 "SVG fragment identifiers" of the latest draft of SVG  introduces
SVG view specifications such as "MyDrawing.svg#svgView(viewBox(0,200,1000,1000)))".
>16.2.2. SVG fragment identifiers
> Shorthand bare name form of addressing (e.g.,
> MyDrawing.svg#MyView). This form of addressing, which
> allows addressing an SVG element by its ID, is compatible
> with the fragment addressing mechanism for older versions of
> HTML and the shorthand bare name formulation in "XML Pointer
> Language (XPointer)" [XPTR]. (The bare name form of addressing
> #MyElement is equivalent to the XPointer formulation
> XPointer-compatible ID reference (e.g.,
> MyDrawing.svg#xptr(id('MyView'))). This form of addressing,
> which also allows addressing an SVG element by its ID, is
> compatible with the syntax for referencing IDs in "XML Pointer
> Language (XPointer)" [XPTR].
> SVG view specification (e.g.,
> MyDrawing.svg#svgView(viewBox(0,200,1000,1000))). This form of
> addressing specifies the desired view of the document (e.g.,
> the region of the document to view, the initial zoom level)
> completely within the SVG fragment specification. The contents
> of the SVG view specification are the five parameter specifications,
> viewBox(...), preserveAspectRatio(...), transform(...),
> allowZoomAndPan(...) and viewTarget(...), whose parameters have
> the same meaning as the corresponding attributes on a <view> element.
Chris Lilley wrote:
> I would like to understand what you mean by "SVG fragment identifier"
> before being able to answer how I feel. I need to understand your
> question better first.
Let me reformulate my question. Suppose that I have an XHTML document.
The first subsection of the second section has an embedded SVG.
I would like to use an XPointer to specify "the SVG in the first subsection
of the second section". Then, I would like to obtain a region of this SVG
by using an SVG view specficiation such as svgView(viewBox(0,200,1000,1000))).
I would like to combine the XPointer and the SVG view specfication to form a
fragment identifier. I think I cannot do this, since SVG view speficiations
require image/svg and XPointer requires text/xml or application/xml (or */*-xml).
Am I right?
#Probably, I am repeating the debate Gavin did long time ago.
Fuji Xerox Information Systems
Tel: +81-44-812-7230 Fax: +81-44-812-7231